Lack of significant coverage in independent, reliable sources.įails WP:GNG, the German Wikipedia article on him was recently deleted for the same notability issues. Protected 4th AFD Note: the show was separately deleted (above) in 2015Ī participant in the AfD found lots of of sources in Spanish that were not used in the article therefore satisfying WP:GNG.ģ new sources found, even split of Keep/delete votesĪ participant in the AfD found sources in French which were not used in the article, therefore satisfying WP:GNG.
Sources were either primary, PR releases, or fake news/spam/blackhat SEO sites Sources were either unreliable or not independent However subsequently deleted in this discussion A participant in the AfD found a number of additional sources that satisfied WP:GNG. 19 January 2019 there was consensus to keep.Īrticle had been in bad shape when it was nominated. Original discussion was closed as delete 11 September 2018. The discussion brought up four independent reliable secondary sources with nontrivial coverage. Relisted twice, with a keep/redirect split. Numbers of subscribers aren't substitutes.įailed WP:GNG - references were only passing mentions rather than being about the YouTuber. Not enough dedicated sources to satisfy GNG. Arguments about WP:ENT are hollow as the person still must meet WP:GNG, and all claims must be verifiable" Recreated in 2018 "Demonstrating notability requires multiple sources. Statistics such as number of views do not carry any weight in these discussions." "The sources, even when in otherwise reliable publications, do not cover the subject in sufficient depth. While number of subscribers does not determine notability, the independent coverage on the subject is enough to pass GNG. Issues surrounding the guideline itself and improvements thereto should be addressed at the guideline's talk page." Now recreated: TheFatRat "Arguments citing that someone is notable for merely being signed to a major label (and/or that they've released a single album via that signing) does not accurately reflect our notability guidelines. WP:A7 as there were no credible references in the article "The number of subscribers *does* have bearing on notability according to the second point of WP:ENT"
Secular Talk Radio - The Kyle Kulinski ShowĪ planned Draft:Luke Lerdwichagul was also deleted. List of the most subscribed users on YouTube The list is not meant to be comprehensive. The following table shows the outcome of a selection of AfD discussions about YouTubers.
0 kommentar(er)
